Track Making Competition 2007 Part II+

Fizz · Post by **Fizz** » Sun Aug 19, 2007 5:33 am

Here are my votes without driving through all of them:
1. Limp_Watery
2. Mini-Craash
3. De_Ficionte

Those are perfect.Ã‹â€¡Ã‹â€¡
There was something in Anizca that wasn't perfect but I don't know what was.

Etmil, your track is good but still there are some bad things about it:
1. The rock in the (i think it was) second curve is too close to the track.
2. The long straight on the top really does bother.

Ice Vally is drivable. The landscape, all the white, really burnt my eyes when driving.

Desert Oasis was quite good to drive but I don't really like the right-left-right-left tracks. They're good to drive on the other hand.

WheelChairBeast was fun to drive. I like the personal style and everything but : what's up with the square-shaped corners?

Anddru · Post by **Anddru** » Sun Aug 19, 2007 11:03 am

1. Jn_Anizca; Very nice track! Good GFX, not to much around the track (to confuse) - smooth lines and good to drive!
2. k-Desert_Oasis; A little like Anizca, but the details are not that great, and not that good to drive, but a good track!
3. de_Ficionte; A good track i think. BUT. Outside the track there is some ogly things (roads with yellow and white lines which not look good). Abouth the PIT - a good idear, but it just doesn't work when you have such a long place with slowdown.
------------------
4. Et_Eldenare; Well, basicly it's a good track, but i do not like the ligthmap on it

5. Limp_Watery; Seems like a track that couldn't be made fast enough.
6. VPA_WheelchairBeast; I do not like the idear of using white lines if they are not smooth. And there a long straight place - boring.
7. URL_Ice_Vally; Seems like a track that couldn't be made fast enough.

Jan · Post by **Jan** » Sun Aug 19, 2007 11:22 am

1. Limp_Watery
2. VPA_WheelchairBeast
3. Jn_Anizca

I drove with all cars, but mostly with antislider and slider.

The difference with these three tracks is very small. I like to drive VPA's track with slider more than Limp-pu's, but with anti somehow Limp-pu's track feels better. Janne's track was great too but doesn't quite make it higher than 3rd. The quality of this competition was great, so thanks to all the trackmakers and the organizers Jarno and Keppana.

Fizz · Post by **Fizz** » Wed Aug 22, 2007 9:27 pm

HEY!
there's only 1 week left so.. everybody who hasn't voted yet.. please do.. the competition isn't over ..

Hengari · Post by **Hengari** » Tue Aug 28, 2007 8:31 pm

This time the competition was tough in the top 5. My votes for the tracks and short comments:

1. Limp_Watery
- Nice track with good feeling. Great with slider and I just don't know how Limp-pu drives this so damn fast.
2. Jn_Anizca
- Again good track from Janne. Challenging with Slider and nice touch when driving.
3. Et_Eldenare
- Excellent track from Etmil. This time the lightmap is not so dark and you can see the obstacles. Could have been nice track even with drawed terrain.
------------------
4. k-Desert_Oasis
- Keppana keeps making better and better tracks but few things like bounces are still on the way. Nice to drive, though.
5. de_Ficionte
- Dede has made good tracks and has learned the tricks what it takes for a good track. Challenging and well made. This time there are those damn tyres so...
6. VPA_WheelchairBeast
- Tight turns and twists. This is VPA.
7. URL_Ice_Vally
- Nice track but could have needed some polishing. The competition is tough.

Limp-pu really made an excellent track especially for Slider. Don't know about other cars and this time I don't care. Keep the flow.

Etmil · Post by **Etmil** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 8:26 am

I've been keeping count of the votes so far, and what I release here is by no means official, but it's still some kind of a standing. Thought that if the deadline is over, why not show my voting table here as well. Of course, Keppana will give you the official results.

Here's the table as a picture: http://www.zone.ee/ziili/trackmaking_co ... esults.jpg
Here's the table as I processed it in .xls format [Microsoft Excel]: http://www.zone.ee/ziili/competition%203.xls

Basically, the podim is as follows:
1. Janne
2. Limp-pu
3. Dede

Congratulations

Keppana · Post by **Keppana** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 9:51 am

Final results:
1. Jn_Anizca 40 pts (33 %)
2. Limp_Watery 33 pts (27 %)
3. de_Ficionte 13 pts (11 %)
4. Et_Eldenare 12 pts (10 %)
5. k-Desert_Oasis 9 pts (7 %)
6. VPA_WheelchairBeast 8 pts (7 %)
7. Mini-Craash 7 pts (6 %)
8. URL_Ice_Vally 1 pt (1 %)

Thanks to all competitors and voters!

Limp-pu · Post by **Limp-pu** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 2:28 pm

Congrats to Janne. Best track won.
I didnt expect my track to be so high in this competition. Anyway thanks to all who voted.

I've already started my track for next TMC. Hope to see many participants and great tracks then too.

Anddru · Post by **Anddru** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 5:13 pm

Keppana wrote:Final results:
1. Jn_Anizca 40 pts (33 %)
2. Limp_Watery 33 pts (27 %)
3. de_Ficionte 13 pts (11 %)
4. Et_Eldenare 12 pts (10 %)
5. k-Desert_Oasis 9 pts (7 %)
6. VPA_WheelchairBeast 8 pts (7 %)
7. Mini-Craash 7 pts (6 %)
8. URL_Ice_Vally 1 pt (1 %)

Thanks to all competitors and voters!

I got a first, a second and a third. That gives 5+3+1 = 9 ?

Etmil · Post by **Etmil** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 5:56 pm

Anddru wrote:I got a first, a second and a third. That gives 5+3+1 = 9 ?

Yes indeed, actually you got a first [Wazaari], a second [Fizz] and two thirds [Tijny and VPA] so that gives 5+3+1+1=10

At least by my calculations.

Post by **Tijny** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 6:11 pm

Etmil wrote:Yes indeed, actually you got a first [Wazaari], a second [Fizz] and two thirds [Tijny and VPA] so that gives 5+3+1+1=10 At least by my calculations.

Hmm, as far as I remember my third place was for Limp-pu, I can't imagine myself having voted on a "rough" track.

Keppana · Post by **Keppana** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 7:48 pm

I made checked calculation and it looks like this, correct if you find it's wrong..

Jn_Anizca 40 pts (32 %)
Limp_Watery 33 pts (26 %)
de_Ficionte 14 pts (11 %)
Et_Eldenare 12 pts (10 %)
k-Desert_Oasis 9 pts (7 %)
Mini-Craash 9 pts (7 %)
VPA_WheelchairBeast 8 pts (6 %)
URL_Ice_Vally 1 pt (1 %)

Etmil · Post by **Etmil** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 8:02 pm

Yeah, the top 3 still remain the same

Anyway, when can we expect the next competition?

Post by **dede** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 8:30 pm

Etmil wrote:Yeah, the top 3 still remain the same Anyway, when can we expect the next competition?

I would like to organize one when TS.com will be released (but the release date isn't up to me anymore). And of course, there will be a racing competition associated as well.

Anddru · Post by **Anddru** » Sat Sep 01, 2007 10:01 pm

I think it could be VERY cool if it was a Rough Track Competetion

Mouse · Post by **Mouse** » Sun Sep 02, 2007 12:00 am

Anddru wrote:I think it could be VERY cool if it was a Rough Track Competetion

That could be a competition of it's own. Who can create the most fun combo of a rough track + ai lines for 20 car chaos.

Jarno · Post by **Jarno** » Sun Sep 02, 2007 7:27 am

Next track competition will be in october.

benzinfurz · Post by **benzinfurz** » Thu Sep 06, 2007 1:07 am

hi all guys ,

i just read that TS.com will be released
is there any date you think you'll be ready dede ?

Mouse · Post by **Mouse** » Thu Sep 06, 2007 3:35 am

benzinfurz wrote:hi all guys ,

i just read that TS.com will be released
is there any date you think you'll be ready dede ?

http://www.jollygoodgames.com/forum/vie ... &start=200

dby · Post by **dby** » Thu Sep 06, 2007 8:39 pm

Hey! Where are the tracks?

I didn't have the time to try them in time for voting, but I wanted to check them out now.

Keppana · Post by **Keppana** » Fri Sep 07, 2007 3:28 pm

Sorry but I did need free space for own stuff, so I had to delete these tracks.